April 24, 20251 yr comment_1793017 Any Edge position player, because that's bad news for Trey, so if we pick an Edge over any defensive linemen I will be mad. Report
April 24, 20251 yr comment_1793019 25 minutes ago, BlackJesus said: Lk4Itwd3ZrIr8YD2.mp4 3.87 MB · 0 downloads Of those 3, I'd prefer Nolen, Pearce, and Green in that order. My concern about Green isn't the SA stuff, but hand size and level of competition. He's getting a lot of mileage from beating Josh Fryar (who will go undrafted) a couple of times. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793120 3 hours ago, sparky151 said: Of those 3, I'd prefer Nolen, Pearce, and Green in that order. My concern about Green isn't the SA stuff, but hand size and level of competition. He's getting a lot of mileage from beating Josh Fryar (who will go undrafted) a couple of times. I would go Nolen first but I think I’d take Green second. He looked impressive in the Sr. Bowl against better completion… and he did play at UVA before Marshall. All good players - I’d take any of them. Report
April 25, 20251 yr Author comment_1793517 On 4/23/2025 at 5:25 PM, BlackJesus said: Duke's recent comments about needing the traits to play in the NFL and not necessarily needing college production makes me think the Bengals are high on the "ideal trait guys" (Mykel Williams & Shemar Stewart). Me the day before the draft ^ Report
April 25, 20251 yr Author comment_1793528 1 hour ago, Inigo Montoya said: He was my puke pick so I guess I win something. I think many were skeptical. But if you haven't watched it yet, look at the 13 minute clip of Chris Simms I put in his draft thread. It's hard not to be excited after watching ... https://forum.go-bengals.com/index.php?/topic/93724-rd-1-bengals-select-~-shemar-stewart-de/page/6/#findComment-1793507 Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793563 7 hours ago, BlackJesus said: I think many were skeptical. But if you haven't watched it yet, look at the 13 minute clip of Chris Simms I put in his draft thread. It's hard not to be excited after watching ... https://forum.go-bengals.com/index.php?/topic/93724-rd-1-bengals-select-~-shemar-stewart-de/page/6/#findComment-1793507 …and then read this (so that you can experience the total rollercoaster effect): I’m still not sure how to feel about this. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793564 11 minutes ago, Cricket said: …and then read this (so that you can experience the total rollercoaster effect): I’m still not sure how to feel about this. 🤮is the best answer It’s the old saying, hope in one hand and shit in the other then see which one fills up first. Report
April 25, 20251 yr Author comment_1793658 This makes me think they would have taken Stewart even with Nolen on the board and Mike Green was never an option. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793672 24 minutes ago, BlackJesus said: This makes me think they would have taken Stewart even with Nolen on the board and Mike Green was never an option. For Bengals fans who fear repeating the past with this pick, at least those flags aren't ones you have to worry about. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793702 1 hour ago, alleycat said: For Bengals fans who fear repeating the past with this pick, at least those flags aren't ones you have to worry about. Someone might want to tell Al Golden about Frostee Rucker. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793768 I notice that agility and technique aren't part of Golden's requirements. They seem tailored to a defense of Stewart more than a general guide. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793774 I don’t think you can criticize Stewart for character, effort, etc. By all accounts, he was loved at A&M and did the right things. The on field stuff is fair game, though. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793794 46 minutes ago, Inigo Montoya said: I don’t think you can criticize Stewart for character, effort, etc. By all accounts, he was loved at A&M and did the right things. The on field stuff is fair game, though. Yeah, nobody is saying he's a bad kid or a slacker. But after 3 years in a top college program, he still hasn't been able to convert his physical gifts into good overall play. That's what makes him a reach. Report
April 25, 20251 yr comment_1793796 Going to give him a little more slack: most of his games were against SEC competition. That is high cotton Report
April 26, 20251 yr comment_1793874 1 hour ago, Le Tigre said: Going to give him a little more slack: most of his games were against SEC competition. That is high cotton Yes, but his sole sack last season was vs Bowling Green. That's why the coachspeak about how hard he worked on Sundays watching film and improving seems like obvious balderdash. Report
April 27, 20251 yr comment_1794700 On 4/15/2025 at 5:59 PM, Le Tigre said: No such thing as a “puke pick”. After any Player X is taken…they will be immediately hailed as the “perfect choice”…”steal”… or whatever other superlative available. Change my mind shiiiit its like youre new here... everyone sucks, everyone was a reach, tobin is already fired to some.. Report
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.