July 5Jul 5 comment_1829899 2 hours ago, Jason said:Anderson is going in the 60s/70s eraGregg/Wyche Mount RushmoreAnthony MunozBoomer Esiason'Tim KrumrieEddie BrownSwitch out Eddie Brown for Ickey Woods and thats mine Report
July 5Jul 5 Author comment_1829901 2 hours ago, Jamie_B said:Switch out Eddie Brown for Ickey Woods and thats mineI'd put James Brooks on way before Ickey.In fact I may replace Eddie with James Report
July 5Jul 5 Author comment_1829902 2 hours ago, High School Harry said:No Eddie Brown.Would David Fulcher fit here?Fulcher very nearly made the list. Had him on, then replaced him with Tim. Report
July 5Jul 5 comment_1829903 30 minutes ago, Jason said:I'd put James Brooks on way before Ickey.In fact I may replace Eddie with JamesI am OK with that.Never really a huge Eddie Brown fan.Seemed to drop too many balls. Report
July 6Jul 6 comment_1829904 1 hour ago, Jason said:Fulcher very nearly made the list. Had him on, then replaced him with Tim.45 minutes ago, High School Harry said:I am OK with that.Never really a huge Eddie Brown fan.Seemed to drop too many balls.I'd drop him for Fulcher. Show the DB's some love!Bengals had some really good ones 70s/80sand no Tory James, no vote 🥷 Report
July 6Jul 6 Author comment_1829919 20 hours ago, BlackJesus said:80s SB EraBoomerMunozIckeyFulcher(I really needed 6-8 slots here)Why Ickey over Brooks? Ickey was great for 1 year, but Brooks put up amazing numbers for several. 🙂 Report
July 6Jul 6 comment_1829922 1 hour ago, Jason said:Why Ickey over Brooks? The wider cultural impact. The Ickey Shuffle is still a thing in the American zeitgeist, whereas Brooks is widely unknown outside of Cincinnati. Report
July 8Jul 8 comment_1829960 On 7/6/2026 at 6:44 PM, BlackJesus said:The wider cultural impact. The Ickey Shuffle is still a thing in the American zeitgeist, whereas Brooks is widely unknown outside of Cincinnati.That part. Report
July 11Jul 11 Author comment_1829995 Pre Super Bowl EraKen AndersonKen RileyBob TrumpyMike Reid Report
July 11Jul 11 comment_1829996 On 7/5/2026 at 1:46 PM, Jason said:Anderson is going in the 60s/70s eraGregg/Wyche Mount RushmoreAnthony MunozBoomer Esiason'Tim KrumrieJames BrooksI would change Brooks for Reggie Williams. Report
July 11Jul 11 comment_1829997 On 7/2/2026 at 5:26 PM, Jason said:Marvin Lewis EraAJ GreenChad JohnsonAndrew WhitworthGeno Atkins.Who you got?I like this group. Dalton and Palmer were impactful but they weren’t better than those four. Report
July 11Jul 11 comment_1830000 10 hours ago, Inigo Montoya said:I would change Brooks for Reggie Williams.no... Report
July 11Jul 11 Author comment_1830001 11 hours ago, Inigo Montoya said:I would change Brooks for Reggie Williams.Reggie was in my original 4 - Munoz, Esiason, Williams, Brown. Then I thought Fulcher instead of Williams. Then settled on Krumrie over both.Then replaced Brown with Brooks to arrive at that four. Report
July 11Jul 11 Author comment_1830002 11 hours ago, Inigo Montoya said:I like this group. Dalton and Palmer were impactful but they weren’t better than those four.Palmer is forever banned from my lists. Quitter. Report
July 11Jul 11 comment_1830004 28 minutes ago, Cat said:You guys just gonna skip over the Dave Shula era, huh? 😄Willie Anderson and Jeff Blake? Caught the tail end anyways...Carl PickensHarold GreenDarnay ScottTough years Report
July 11Jul 11 Author comment_1830007 1 hour ago, Cat said:You guys just gonna skip over the Dave Shula era, huh? 😄see dark decade Report
July 11Jul 11 comment_1830008 6 hours ago, Jason said:see dark decadeNo....Gary Reasons was the epitome of Shulas tenure....6 hours ago, Jason said:see dark decadeDark indeed... Report
July 11Jul 11 comment_1830009 7 hours ago, Cat said:You guys just gonna skip over the Dave Shula era, huh? 😄Gary Reasons ring a bell? Report
Thursday at 04:34 PM2 days Author comment_1830101 I’m going to do two more. Today the Icons Mount Rushmore. National attention. Not necessarily just as a player. Ickey WoodsChad JohnsonBoomer EsiasonCris Collinsworth Report
Thursday at 04:51 PM2 days comment_1830102 15 minutes ago, Jason said:I’m going to do two more.Today the Icons Mount Rushmore. National attention. Not necessarily just as a player.Ickey WoodsChad JohnsonBoomer EsiasonCris CollinsworthCollinsworth gets more attention for being a blowhard than being a Bengal. Report
Thursday at 09:21 PM2 days Author comment_1830107 4 hours ago, Dautcom08 said:Collinsworth gets more attention for being a blowhard than being a Bengal.I thunk he is largely misunderstood by the fanbase. He is a great announcer because he is unbiased. He credits good teams and good players. He's not a homer in his work so he praises guys and teams we hate.But in private, or on Bengals related media his fandom is obvious. Report
Friday at 12:18 PM1 day comment_1830112 19 hours ago, Jason said:I’m going to do two more.Today the Icons Mount Rushmore. National attention. Not necessarily just as a player.Ickey WoodsChad JohnsonBoomer EsiasonCris CollinsworthIn your opinion, is Joe Burrow going to eventually replace one of these guys? If so, which one? Report
Friday at 09:39 PM1 day Author comment_1830126 9 hours ago, Shebengal said:In your opinion, is Joe Burrow going to eventually replace one of these guys? If so, which one?Interesting question. Yes, I think he will. As to which, I would lean Boomer. Collinsworth garners a lot of national attention. Report
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.