Posted December 17, 201212 yr comment_1194921 I don't know if I would vote for him or not. But I would not be too upset if he got in. I thought he was a Hall caliber player before he started juicing. But if he does get in, he should have an asterisk by his name. Sosa does not belong.
December 17, 201212 yr comment_1194961 I would vote him in. He was a hall of famer before he started juicing and when he did he was better then all of the others. Bonds unlike the other steroid users was just not about home runs. He was a great fielder and base stealer. He was one of the greatest players to ever play the game but he will never get the recognition he deserves.
December 18, 201212 yr comment_1195141 [quote name='CincyInDC' timestamp='1355828065' post='1195096'] Only if Pete were let in too. [/quote] This...
December 20, 201212 yr comment_1195759 [quote name='CincyInDC' timestamp='1355828065' post='1195096'] Only if Pete were let in too. [/quote] x3 And as long as the MLB takes the position it takes on Pete, it's a stain for any of these juicers to make it in. Otherwise qualified or not.
December 20, 201212 yr Author comment_1195857 [quote name='sois' timestamp='1355776732' post='1194922'] Why no poll? Failthread. [/quote] Because I wanted people to elaborate an opinion, not just cast a vote. Failpost.
December 20, 201212 yr comment_1195918 [quote name='Jason' timestamp='1356025241' post='1195857'] Because I wanted people to elaborate an opinion, not just cast a vote. Failpost. [/quote] Yeah, because a poll makes it impossible to elaborate on your vote. Good one.
December 25, 201212 yr comment_1198902 not for a long while, but probably eventually.... mostly because i have heard so many stories about him being a racist dirtbag off the baseball field.
December 28, 201212 yr Author comment_1199885 [quote name='sois' timestamp='1356038672' post='1195918'] Yeah, because a poll makes it impossible to elaborate on your vote. Good one. [/quote] Whenever I do a poll I get far more votes than I do posts. Plus counting is not that hard.
January 4, 201312 yr comment_1203267 Sure. You had guys use greenies for years, and nobody complained about the competitive advantage. This only occurred because baseball's most Sacred records, the Home Run Record for a year and a career, was being taken down. The fact is, that of the people caught using roids, over 55% have been pitchers. Barry Belongs in the Hall, and so does Pete.
January 4, 201312 yr comment_1203268 [quote name='Dalton4HOF' timestamp='1356413822' post='1198902'] not for a long while, but probably eventually.... mostly because i have heard so many stories about him being[b] a racist dirtbag off the baseball field.[/b] [/quote] that never stopped them from putting Ty Cobb and a bunch of players from that era in the Hall.
January 7, 201312 yr comment_1205965 [quote name='kennethmw' timestamp='1357314466' post='1203268'] that never stopped them from putting Ty Cobb and a bunch of players from that era in the Hall. [/quote] what? how does that even make sense? was ty cobb a dirtbag? did ty cobb hate black fans? living in an era of segregation literally, LITERALLY has nothing to do with a modern day players racist behavior. are you kidding me?
January 7, 201312 yr comment_1205967 [quote name='Dalton4HOF' timestamp='1357579163' post='1205965'] what? how does that even make sense? [b]was ty cobb a dirtbag? did ty cobb hate black fans?[/b] living in an era of segregation literally, LITERALLY has nothing to do with a modern day players racist behavior. are you kidding me? [/quote] Uh, yeah he was. He was also known to beat the shit out of black people for fun among other questionable conduct...
January 9, 201312 yr comment_1206794 [url="http://espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/8828339/no-players-elected-baseball-hall-fame-writers"]http://espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/8828339/no-players-elected-baseball-hall-fame-writers[/url]
January 15, 201312 yr comment_1208236 [quote name='Dalton4HOF' timestamp='1357579163' post='1205965'] what? how does that even make sense? was ty cobb a dirtbag? did ty cobb hate black fans? living in an era of segregation literally, LITERALLY has nothing to do with a modern day players racist behavior. are you kidding me? [/quote] You need a history lesson, don't you?
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.