May 6, 20223 yr comment_1671074 6 hours ago, sparky151 said: I'm not questioning whether the Bengals liked Carter more than other teams or not. They clearly did. What's in question is whether they were right to do so and also to take him in the top 100. The argument that the Bengals draft D-lineman well in the midrounds seems to rest entirely on Geno Atkins. He certainly outperformed his draft position. Other than him, are you going back to Domata Peko? While ignoring the Shelvins, Wrens, etc? Yes. Peko was a pretty solid Nose Guard for most of his time here. I will go back to Peko without hesitation. That's not hard for me at all. And we know next to nothing about about Shelvin so far, other than he played pretty well in situational run stopping designed to stop Derik Henry in the playoff game.
May 6, 20223 yr Author comment_1671075 3 minutes ago, Jamie_B said: we know next to nothing about about Shelvin so far, Just having Shelvin there to hoist Burrow on his shoulders for the iconic moment after making the Super Bowl (recreating their LSU motif) makes him worth his draft pick. Plus I think he will actually be in the short yardage rotation this year.
May 6, 20223 yr comment_1671085 11 hours ago, BlackJesus said: Just having Shelvin there to hoist Burrow on his shoulders for the iconic moment after making the Super Bowl (recreating their LSU motif) makes him worth his draft pick. Plus I think he will actually be in the short yardage rotation this year. Shelvin is basically Readers backup and I suspect will get more time this year. If they drafted well here then he should take over the starting role for cheaper than Reader was after the 23 season.
May 6, 20223 yr comment_1671146 And in a year or so Shelvin will most likely replace Tupou. IDL of Shelvin's size take a few years.
May 7, 20223 yr comment_1671182 16 hours ago, membengal said: And in a year or so Shelvin will most likely replace Tupou. IDL of Shelvin's size take a few years. I doubt it's even a year or two I bet Shelvin has that role this year.
May 11, 20223 yr comment_1671288 Jason Buck. Don’t know why his name pops into my head when I read about this guy?
May 11, 20223 yr Author comment_1671309 I will say, his cut build gives off an Aaron Donald (no fat % vibe) ... Let's hope it leads to "cat-like" quickness inside
May 11, 20223 yr comment_1671311 I trust hobby the d line coach to get this guy right he is a awesome d line coach one of the nfl s best
May 11, 20223 yr comment_1671316 20 hours ago, Le Tigre said: Jason Buck. Don’t know why his name pops into my head when I read about this guy? I hope not - Buck was an undersized edge only guy.
May 11, 20223 yr comment_1671317 12 minutes ago, membengal said: I hope not - Buck was an undersized edge only guy. The Bengals ran a 3-4 heavy defense back then. Krumrie was solely over center, and Buck/Jim Skow were sort of DE, sort of outside the guard/tackle gaps. They both even dropped into coverage at times. I don’t know…like I said, reading about Carter just caused Buck and Skow to pop in the mind Skow wasn’t all that big either
May 12, 20223 yr comment_1671325 Correct - he would on occasion drop out into coverage. In any event, he definitely was not kicking inside. Carter reminds me more in terms of measurements of Jonathan Fanene who was mostly inside - Fanene was 6'4" 285.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.